Your District Committee Meeting

Sometime between the time you apply for a license to practice law and your swearing-in day, there exists moments of anxiety.  It might come in of the form of a letter from the State Bar of Michigan’s Character & Fitness department or your own knowledge that something happened in your recent or distant past for which you know you’ll have to answer to someone.  Some people get e-mails asking for clarification on an application question and that simple inquiry is enough to distract or even despair.   Of course, it does not take much to distract any applicant waiting for approval from the State Bar of Michigan and ultimately from the Board of Law Examiners.

The District Committee

When circumstances dictate, an applicant will be called into an in-person meeting with State Bar incarnated in the form of a District Committee.  The District Committee is made up of lawyers appointed by the State Bar of Michigan’s Board of Commissioners based upon their locality.  The districts correspond to the State Bar of Michigan’s geographic regions.  The members of the committee are appointed for three years.  All members of the committee are volunteers.  It is considered an honor to be a member of the District Committee and the individual members take their work seriously.

It is considered an ‘informal’ meeting according to the Rules on Admission to the State Bar.  The roles and duties of Committee members are dictated by the State Bar rules regarding character & fitness.  The conduct of the district committee meetings are dictated by the same rules.  All the meetings are taped though the contents of the meeting are not transcribed nor are the tapes available to the applicant.  The District Committee will meet, review the applicant’s application, meet with and interview the candidate and make a decision about the candidate’s fitness.  They will then issue an opinion which is reviewed by the Standing Committee on Character & Fitness who can either accept the District’s recommendation and pass the approved application to the Board of Law Examiners for their approval, accept the recommendation but still want to meet with the candidate or reject the applicant giving the applicant the opportunity to appear before a standing committee to make the case for an applicant’s requisite character & fitness.  The candidate may bring a lawyer to the meeting as well as other supporting materials that might affect the committee’s decision.

A candidate who will have to meet with the District Committee will receive a letter and a referral sheet from the State Bar of Michigan’s Character & Fitness department.  The meeting will then be scheduled through the District Committee chairman’s office.  The Chairman will then find three to five members of the District Committee who will agree to sit on the applicant’s panel.  The panelists will have the application and the referral sheet of the applicant.  The committee’s readiness is dictated by the amount of time they have had to prepare for the meeting.  Most issues are straight-forward enough, but some issues do contain subtleties.

Bringing an attorney to a District Committee meeting is a matter of comfort and preference.  Most issues do not require a lawyer but rather thorough preparation and honest responses.  The advantage to having a lawyer and consulting with a lawyer prior to the meeting is to reduce the ’surprise’ factor and to properly prepare you to honestly answer the questions you will get.  The attorney will also prepare you to meet the burden of proof for the hearing: you are responsible to prove by clear and convincing evidence that you possess the requisite character & fitness to practice law.  It is not presumed.
(Read more…)

How to Apply for The State Bar of Michigan

      This post is NOT a replacement for the www.michbar.org directions and forms.  No, this is more of a practical article on how to approach the State Bar of Michigan’s application. 

1.     First Look at the Forms.  The application and supporting forms are lengthy and require massive detail.  Everywhere you have lived, all of your previous employment, all of your schooling and just about all other aspects of your life are addressed by the forms.  You will see that if you need more room to complete the application, you will have to supplement it with the additional forms.  It would be a good idea to simply review a printed out copy and make a list of what you will need.

2.     Dig Up Your Past.  All of your movements, any change of address, change of employment, enrollment or disenrollment from school, lawsuits, firings, arrests, etc . . . .   Every instance where your life was in flux involved some paperwork.  Before you answer any questions, get all of that paperwork together.  Your memory of the incident might not jive with the ‘official’ record and why do you want to create a question of fact.  You would be surprised to see what official reports, landlord references, employment files and your credit reports really say about you.  I am not sugesting that you parrot their contents, but at least you have to acknowledge their existance in your answers.

3.     Start Early.  If you lived out of state or out of country, you will have to do some scrambling to chase down all the different criminal clearances, driver’s records, addresses where you lived and worked and anything else that is pertinent.  This takes some time (Remember the old saw: an emergency on your part does not necessarily create an emergency on my part).  I always recommend 2 1/2 months prior to the day you want to turn in your application.

4.     Be Open and Honest.  Why people want to hide all of their business is perfectly understandable.  After all, we are an image-conscious society that promotes positive images.  No matter, you need to be open with your licensing board.  You are seeking one of the most powerful and potentially lucrative business licenses available.  It gives wide discretion to act on behalf of yourself and your clients.  So, the Board of Law Examiners (BLE) and the State Bar of Michigan (SBM) wants to know as much as they can.  The basic information you provide in your application is not only taken at face value, but is used to develop its own independant information.  So, if you do have any advere information about yourself in the public record, you can be sure it will be discovered.  Better you do it and explain it fully rather than have the SBM invetigator find it and flag your file.  Failing to disclose known information is a big sin in the eyes of the SBM and The BLE.

5.     Anticipate and Address Adverse Information Early and Often.  OK, maybe you shop-lifted some stuff when you were a kid or got caught with marijuana (aka marihuana in MI statute) in high school.  You may have done something more severe such as a felony or a serious misdemeanor.  Cheating, lying or misrepresenting yourself are matters that bring your character into question.  There a number of lawyers who have done such things before they were licensed.  Today, even something like poorly managed finances will get your file flagged.  If you know you have problems (or think you might have problems), you not only need to fully and properly disclose them, you need to have your plan of action/reconciliation/penance/reformation on hand to show the SBM that whatever transgression occurred in the past, it will not occur again because a), b), c) . . . .  This is critical.  It is indicative of you current character & fitness.  If you have not really addressed the issue that may be adverse to a determination of your character & fitness, you can start something today (like the Lawyers & Judges Assistance Program [sponsored by SBM for lawyers and law students alike] for addictive behaviors) and include that in your application or simply delay your application until you got your problem/issue under management and then submit it.

      You need to be honest with yourself.  If in doubt, check it out.  Maybe you are paranoid.  maybe you are in denial that a problem exists.  Either way, a bit of introspection and some sound legal advice will probably confirm your gut feeling on how your problem is perceived and how it will affect your chances to be admitted.

6.     Supplement Your Answers.  You need to supplement your application whenever there is a change.  Good, bad or otherwise, you must supplement your form until you are cleared by the BLE and sworn into the courts.  Michigan law licenses are not conditional.  Once issued, you are vested in a valuable property right.  That’s one reason why our process is so strict.  By doing so, you are upholding your written promise found in the form.

      The Take Away for You- A law license is a valuable commodity.  Practicing law is a privilege.  The SBM guards its monopoly and the BLE will act just as carefully.  This means you need to be just as meticulous and careful.  If you are thorough and detailed in your preparation, you will not have a problem being licensed.  Even if you have adverse information in your application, your open, honest answers (and proposed solutions) will be given more credence compared to someone else’s slapdash application.

Don’t Be Afraid to Ask For Help!

If you have failed the bar, don’t despair. OK, you can despair a little. But you need to do a couple of things:

1. Order Your Results: No matter how bad you did, get the results and get some feedback.

2. See if You Have Some Other Options: Maybe you can appeal. Maybe you’re held up by Character & Fitness. Look at your letter close and see what the Bar’s hang-up is.

3. Plan to Take The Bar Again: You have far too much invested in school and in your future. If need be, take the Exam again. If you do, make sure what ever you are doing is going to work.

Easy? . . . . No . . . Necessary? . . . . Yes. Call our office for a read through of your test, your preparation for the test or other issues on your mind.

Why I Write Michigan Bar Appeals

The simple answer is for the fame and fortune associated with it.  But since this area of law offers neither, I have to fall back to my real reason.

A good part of my practice focuses on counseling legal professionals in transition.  This includes teaching bar examination prep classes, tutoring students, counseling applicants delayed in their application process because of Character & Fitness issues and helping young lawyers make the adjustment from law student to lawyer.  I am writing a book to help law students prepare for the examination and am getting ready to write another book on how to open a solo practice.  My own experience becoming a lawyer pointed up the lack of assistance during this transaction and the great need for guidance and advice.  Over the years, I have encountered so many people who needed advice about Character & Fitness, how to reapply for the Bar Examination or simply finding the motivation to retake the Exam.

At first, I began to offer advice to these new lawyers informally.  I mentored as I was mentored.  Generally speaking, this has been how the practice has been taught and handed down – a combination of mumbled advice and presumed osmosis from which we are supposed to base our career.  It was not very satisfying nor helpful.  As our practice grows, there are fewer of the familiar relationships in place that promote open dialogue and sharing.  Toughen up and put your shoulder into it.  Everyone else is fine . . . what is your hang up?  Ah, but I digress.

The thing is that the transition from law student to lawyer is difficult.  The dizzying mix of personal and professional demands is, at best, challenging and causes no small measure of stress that can cause other problems.  Even worse, some people discover that the practice of law is not like the brochures or Boston Legal.  Again, I digress.

No matter what, if you have taken the Michigan Bar Examination and not passed, you may be looking for help and advice.  I fully understand that feeling.  Back in November 1993, I waited for my bar results anxiously as my new job (and my government career) depended upon them.  On November 2, 1993, the carpet was pulled out from under me.  I missed by two points (actually 1.667 points but the Board of Law Examiners rounds up).  No, that was not the news I expected.  I worked hard on studying, sacrificed my summer and put all my chips on the fact I would pass.

I was stunned.  I did not know what to do.  I did not know who to tell.  I did tell my boss who was, at first, kind and understanding, but then told me the position held for me had to be filled by someone else.  I told my family and friends.  I heard all my friends passed and were making arrangements for get sworn in.  I felt like a total loser whose winter months were going to be devoted to studying for the Bar Examination once again.

I spoke to my professors and my sister-in-law who told me to appeal my score.  Appeal?  Appeal what?  I did not even know that was an option.  I assumed it was a test and a test is a test.  Well, it’s right in the Michigan Court Rules and tersely explained in the ‘failure packet’.  OK, now what?  How do I do it?  Can I do my own?  Pen or pencil?  does neatness count?

Thank God for the good advice I received.  With the help of Megan and Prof. Jack, I put my nose to the grindstone and knocked out my own bar appeal.  To say I obsessed over it would be an understatement.  I analyzed, reviewed, read and reread the materials:  my answer, the Model Answer, the directions from the Michigan Board of Law Examiners.  Draft upon draft until I had it just right.  Conservatively, I spent about 70 hours on the whole project.  I developed the basics for the same approach that I use today in writing appeals.  Of course I did not believe I was going to ever do it again.  I thought I would succeed, but after failing the Bar Exam and losing my job, betting against the house did not seem real smart.
(Read more…)

Honesty is The Only Policy

Your application for membership in the State Bar of Michigan is lengthy and requires considerable effort to complete.  It could take months to gather all the necessary information before you are done.  Consider this:  If you have lived anywhere for more than two weeks, you must list it on your application.  That includes dorm rooms, the three month sublet in Wahington, D.C. and even an overseas address for a summer study.

All of your jobs must be listed: dishwasher, parking attendant, part-time or full-time; jobs you quit, jobs that were seasonsal, jobs you were fired from.  There is a lot of disclosure required for your finances.  Any contact with law enforcement – must be disclosed.  (Check out the form at www.michbar.org)

Maybe there are some things you forgot to disclose on your law school application.  Perhaps you were too embarrassed or worried how it would reflect on your appearance to the school or the general public.

Whatever the case is, you must bare all on your Application to the State Bar of Michigan.  Full and honest disclosure is needed to avoid unnecessary delays in your clearance.  This process is a confidential one, but requires you to be open and frank about all the skeletons in your closet.  It is quite explicit in the directions, but becomes even more clear when you go through the process.  (Read more…)

How Michigan Bar Examinations Are Graded

The Michigan Board of Law Examiners promulgated, administers and grades the Michigan Bar Examination. It is offered twice a year. Each time it is administered, a company of legal professionals is enlisted to get you your grade.

The Multistate Bar Examination

The Multistate Bar questions are graded by the National Board of Law Examiners. That part of your exam is automatically graded and available to the Board soon after the Bar Exam is administered.

The Michigan Essay Examination

The Michigan Board of Law Examiners is made up of 5 members.  Each member is responsible for 3 of the 15 essay questions.  To assist in the grading, the Board member hires three graders to assist in the grading. Each grader is responsible to grade one question.  The Bar Examination blue books go between each grader where the initial grades are assigned.

After the initial grades are assigned, these scores are paired with the MBE scores to determine who passed and who did not. If the score falls between 130-134, those papers are re-graded by different graders to see if any more points will be awarded. After the regrading process is complete, the Board of Law Examiners ‘curves’ the test according to an unpublished formula.  In the February 2009 Bar Examination, this added, on average, 5.66 points.  Once the adjusted scores are recorded, the official letters are sent out to the bar candidates.

How The Answers Are Graded

As to grading individual answers, the graders are looking for answers that are 1) responsive to the question asked, 2) citing the correct law, 3) analytical as to key facts and 4) come to the right conclusion.  As the grader reads over 1000 versions of the answer, they usually spend no more than 60-90 seconds to grade the answer.  They’re looking for terms of art applicable to the question, organization comporting with the Call of the question and readability.  The graders do not use the Model Answer as a grading rubric, but a ‘checklist’ or ‘tally sheet’ published in-house to speed the process.  In as much as the grader reads the same question over and over, they are quite familiar with what should be present in the answer.

No one claims to get it right each time.  Subjectivity, fatigue and misreading an answer are all possibilities why an answer may not get the credit it deserves or gets greater credit than would be warranted.  The graders are trying to find the credit you deserve but more importantly they are upholding the integrity of the test.

Should You Do Your Own Bar Appeal?

If you are reading this before the results are released, you’re are too worried or just morbidly curious.

The release of Michigan Bar Examination results is a time frought with joy and anguish.  Not everyone gets the news they want.  But before you start reading though your study materials again, you need to consider your choices.  The Michigan Board of Law Examiners has a procedure that allows those candidates who did not pass the Michigan Bar Examination to appeal the results of their essay scores. This procedure is found in Michigan Court Rules 9.1 et seq. See http://coa.courts.mi.gov/rules/documents/7RulesForTheBoardOfLawExaminers.pdf  for the exact rules and procedure.  As of the publication of this piece, Michigan’s passing score is still 135 out of 200 (67.5%).

Assuming that you did not pass the bar, you first need to consider whether you should do an appeal or not. As a rule of thumb, if you need more than 10 raw points, a successful appeal will difficult. Raw points are the points derived from the essay scores before they are calculated with your MBE score. The formula used to equalize the MBE and Essay scores is as follows: Raw Score from all 15 essays x 4/3 = adjusted score. The adjusted score is then modified by the ‘curve’ determined by the Board of Law Examiners. In February 2009, this curve added approximately 5.66 points to the adjusted raw score. By the way, that formula is not disclosed to the public.  By calculating your adjusted score, you should be able to determine how many raw points (i.e. extra essay points) you need to boost your score to an overall score of 135.

If you are within 10 points, then you need to look at your individual answers to see if you were undergraded on any of them and, if so, by how much.  This requires you to objective review your own scores and determine whether you addressed the question and how well you did so.  You have to be critical and objective to do this best.

The next part is tougher. Now you need to look at the Model Answers from the Michigan Bar Examination to see what it was the graders were looking for. This is tough because sometimes, the model answers are not entirely clear on how points are awarded.

With your questions identified and your arguments ready, writing the appeal is more about substance than form. If you feel strongly about the questions you are appealing, make the best argument you can. Don’t make it personal, but focus on the objective arguments.
(Read more…)